European soccer clubs file a complaint with European Commission to challenge UEFA and rival teams

EFSA

A new development in soccer politics emerged on Monday when lower-ranked clubs took a stand against the deep connections established clubs have with UEFA. The Union of European Clubs (UEC), representing 140 members, has submitted a complaint to the European Commission in Brussels over UEFA’s legal agreement with the influential European Football Clubs group (EFC), led by Paris Saint-Germain president Nasser al-Khelaifi, which runs until 2033. The EFC currently represents approximately 800 European clubs.

The UEC contends that the EFC’s exclusive access to UEFA to negotiate competition entries and distribute billions in prize money harms competitive balance, effectively enabling a select few clubs to maintain their dominance in the Champions League. The UEC’s concerns about anti-competitive practices and the abuse of a dominant position mirror those voiced by clubs involved in the European Super League, which secured a 2023 ruling against UEFA and FIFA at the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg.

“This case aims to use European competition law to protect the integrity of the European sports model, ensuring genuinely open and balanced competitions,” remarked Professor Miguel Maduro, an independent governance expert, former Advocate General at the Court of Justice of the EU and former Chair of FIFA’s Governance and Review Committee.

“A system where a select group of elite clubs is given the power to decide who gets to compete in European competitions, and how the revenues are distributed, does not only harm competition in European and national football. It gradually destroys the model of open and balanced competition that UEFA itself claims to protect. If UEFA is truly committed to that model, it should welcome this complaint as a way to challenge the growing power of the elite clubs and better protect all football stakeholders,” said Prof. Maduro.

This is the second soccer-related complaint submitted to the European Commission. In 2024, the European Leagues group, alongside the European division of the global players’ union FIFPRO, alleged that FIFA was not properly consulting on decisions that favoured its commercial interests, including expanding competitions. FIFPRO later reached an agreement with FIFA, leading to the withdrawal of its complaint.

Since its formation in 2023, the UEC has included clubs such as Union Saint-Gilloise, Levante, Osasuna, Burnley, St. Pauli, and Aberdeen. One key proposal UEFA did not adopt was to share 5% of the annual revenues from the three European club competitions with the teams that developed the participating players. The UEC estimated that implementing this policy could have shared €67 million last season among clubs outside of the top-tier divisions.

This article used information from The Associated Press.

Explore more